Sand Canyon Venues · Part 5 · The Deadline
Five O’Clock Came and Went: Santa Clarita Was Asked Ten Questions About a Donor’s Wedding Venue. It Answered None of Them.
The City Manager opened the letter within 24 minutes. The Clerk’s office turned it into a records request within two hours. Six days later, the City has explained nothing — not the three “temporary” permits, not the hearing that never happened, not the $7,000, not the sign. The questions stay open. So does the record of who read them and said nothing.
By I. Martinez, Good Shepherd Media · Santa Clarita · November 17, 2026
What was asked, and of whom
On November 9 and 10, Good Shepherd Media put the public record on The Barn at Rancho Deluxe to the City of Santa Clarita in writing — to City Manager Ken Striplin, City Clerk Melody Bartlette, Senior Code Enforcement Officer Daniel Ramirez and Community Preservation’s Masis Hagobian — and asked for answers by 5:00 p.m. Monday, November 16. The record was the City’s own: ten documents it produced on November 5 showing a film-studio barn in an Open Space zone, where the Code says any use not listed is prohibited, operating a year-round wedding business on three consecutive one-year staff-signed temporary permits, with a 296-seat assembly room certified under a 200-guest cap, a permanent “Weddings and Events” sign standing under a permit that forbids permanent signage, and a third permit accepted nine days after this publication’s complaints reached City Hall. The full report, with every document, is here.
The questions were specific. Under what provision of the Unified Development Code is a commercial wedding venue a permitted use in the OS-A zone? Why were three one-year Class II permits issued for a use that Section 17.67.030(S) sends to a Class IV public hearing after the first year? Were neighbors ever notified? Who processed Master Case 26-132, on what date, and did anyone in the City Manager’s office or on the Council communicate with Planning about it between September 13 and 23? Has Councilmember Jason Gibbs disclosed the $7,000 he received from the property’s owners on September 29, 2025, in connection with any Rancho Deluxe matter, as Government Code section 84308 requires? Why did three neighboring venues get code-enforcement cases while this one got a permit? And a formal request for enforcement: determine in writing whether Temporary Use Permit 26-024 was lawfully issued, and if not, suspend it and send the applicant to the hearing the Code requires.
The same letter went, with the published report attached, to Councilmember Gibbs and to the venue, each of whom had already been asked for comment in October.
What the City did instead
It read the letter. Mr. Hagobian’s mail system returned a read receipt at 12:10 p.m. on November 10, thirteen minutes after the letter was sent. Mr. Striplin’s returned one at 12:21 p.m. Ms. Bartlette had opened the previous night’s objection to the City’s records withholding at 11:56 p.m.
Then, at 1:58 p.m. the same day, the City Clerk’s office logged the letter as Public Records Act Request #11317932, with an estimated resolution date of November 20. It is the ninth Good Shepherd Media press letter the City has converted into a records request since October. A records request receives a determination within ten days and, routinely, a fourteen-day extension. It does not receive an answer to a question. Not one of the questions put to the City about these venues since September — about the Movie Ranch overlay, about the Triumph Avenue wedding filmed on October 18, about the “Sikhs of Service” sign on Rolling Hills Avenue, about the Barn — has been answered by any City official in any form.
As of 5:00 p.m. Monday, November 16, 2026, Good Shepherd Media had received no response from the City of Santa Clarita, from Councilmember Gibbs, or from The Barn at Rancho Deluxe to any of the questions above. No correction to the published report was offered by anyone. Nothing in it has been disputed.
What silence does and does not establish
It does not establish wrongdoing. A city that declines to answer a newspaper may have reasons it considers good, and an open code-enforcement case remains an allegation, not a finding. Good Shepherd Media does not allege that any official or any private person has committed a crime.
What silence does establish is the state of the record. The record, as of today, is this: the City’s own documents show a wedding business in a zone that prohibits it, approved three times at staff level without a hearing, for owners who are contributors to a sitting Councilmember, while three non-contributing competitors on the same kind of land were put under investigation. Asked to explain the difference, the City chose not to. Asked whether the permit was lawful, the City chose not to say. Asked whether its Councilmember disclosed the contribution, the City chose not to say. Those are choices, and they are now part of the record alongside the permits.
What happens next
The questions do not expire. The City’s own records clocks now run: November 19 for the Barn’s compliance file — every seven-day wedding notice since 2022, every complaint, the conditions of the 2026 permit — and for two earlier requests; November 20 for the four-parcel zoning status and for this letter; November 23 for the October correspondence on Rolling Hills Avenue and the four-venue letter. Each of those dates will be reported the same way: what the City produced, or that it produced nothing.
The request for enforcement stands. Good Shepherd Media has asked the City to determine whether Temporary Use Permit 26-024 was lawfully issued and, if it was not, to suspend it. California law treats a land use that violates a zoning ordinance as a public nuisance per se, and the City applied that law to the Barn’s three neighbors. It has not said why it will not apply it to the Barn. Good Shepherd Media has reserved its remedies under the Public Records Act for the records the City is withholding; those remedies are not a newspaper’s only recourse, and they are not the neighbors’.
Every question in this series remains open to the City, to Councilmember Gibbs and to the venue. Any answer, at any time, will be published in full and unedited, with the same prominence as this report. The offer has been on the table since September. It is still there.
The record
- November 9, 10:29 p.m. — Objection to the City’s §7923.600(a) withholding of the Rolling Hills, Triumph and Josel files; new Public Records Act request for the Barn’s permit-compliance records. Read by the City Clerk 11:56 p.m.
- November 10, 11:57 a.m. — Questions A–J and request for enforcement, four photographs attached. Read by Mr. Hagobian 12:10 p.m., Mr. Striplin 12:21 p.m. Logged by the City as PRA #11317932 at 1:58 p.m.
- November 10, 1:39 p.m. — Supplement: the venue’s current advertising, the contribution record of all four operators, and the draft report, provided for correction before publication.
- November 10, 3:33 p.m. — Report published. 3:45 p.m. — Publication notice to the City, Councilmember Gibbs and the venue, restating the November 16 deadline.
- November 16, 5:00 p.m. — Deadline. No response received from any party.
I Martinez – Investigative Reporter –
Business Fraud • Misuse of Land • Zoning Violations • City Responses to Local Issues
Prior reports in this series: The Barn at Rancho Deluxe · Rolling Hills Avenue · Thirty-nine days. An open code-enforcement case is an allegation, not a finding.
